To prove we're right, we give you five home videos of total amateurs doing their earnest refreshes of Chesney's material — their passion for the songs in place of Chesney's unique on-stage persona. Tell us whether you think they stand up to the originals, and also don't forget to sign up for our Kenny Chesney contest on Facebook — your chance to fly to Green Bay with a friend to see Chesney live and meet the artist backstage.

"Somewhere with You" by measter17

"There Goes My Life" by MJ Hong

"Me and You" by calebgracemusic

"You Had Me From Hello" by TyBlakeBarham

"Better as a Memory" by derekcate