The hunt for the perfect piece of pie is a delicate one. One that is extremely contentious, and rarely do pie connoisseurs come to a unanimous conclusion.

Here's our best guess at the top five spots in the state for pie, feel free to disagree and comment with your own opinions/suggestions!

 

  • Purestock, ThinkStock Images
    1

    Sherrie's Place

    Casper

    135 Google reviews, and they have 5 out of 5 stars. This was an easy pick for the top spot.

  • Getty Images
    2

    Pie Lady

    Cheyenne

    Not only do they serve the best slice of pie in the capital city, they do homemade dinners too.

  • Chaloner Woods, Getty Images
    3

    Persephone Bakery

    Jackson

    It was tough to add this since they aren't a dedicated pie-specific place. But, you have to try their apple crostata.

  • 4

    Cowboy Cafe

    Dubois

    Giant homemade pies that come with an ice cream option!

  • Townsquare Media
    5

    The-Pie-Tin

    Wheatland

    Pie is in the name! We recommend their butterscotch pie.